The Common Mistake in Integrating a Product

Integration distributes over addition and subtraction but never over multiplication. Integrating each factor of a product and multiplying the results is the single most common mistake in integration - here is why it fails, and what to do instead.

--

Integration splits neatly over addition and subtraction, so it feels as though it should split over multiplication in the same way. It does not. Integrating each factor of a product on its own and multiplying the results is the single most common mistake in integration.

Note Addition and subtraction really do split

Integration passes term by term through a sum or a difference:

 \int \big(f(x) \pm g(x)\big)\,dx = \int f(x)\,dx \;\pm\; \int g(x)\,dx

Take  2x , whose integral is  x^{2} + C . Break it up across a plus sign and integrate the pieces:

 2x = x + x , so  \displaystyle\int 2x\,dx = \int x\,dx + \int x\,dx = \dfrac{x^{2}}{2} + \dfrac{x^{2}}{2}
 x^{2} + C
Break it across a minus sign instead and the pieces still reassemble:
 2x = 3x - x , so  \displaystyle\int 2x\,dx = \int 3x\,dx - \int x\,dx = \dfrac{3x^{2}}{2} - \dfrac{x^{2}}{2}
 x^{2} + C

Split the function however you like across  + and  - , integrate each part, and the answer always comes back correct.

Note Multiplication does not split

There is no matching rule for a product. Writing one down is the mistake:

 \int f(x)\,g(x)\,dx \;\neq\; \left( \int f(x)\,dx \right)\!\left( \int g(x)\,dx \right)
Example Watch the wrong method fail

Integrate  \displaystyle\int x^{2}\cdot x\,dx , first the wrong way, then the right way.

Integrate each factor separately and multiply the results:
 \displaystyle\int x^{2}\,dx = \dfrac{x^{3}}{3}, \qquad \int x\,dx = \dfrac{x^{2}}{2}
 \dfrac{x^{3}}{3}\cdot\dfrac{x^{2}}{2} = \dfrac{x^{5}}{6}  — wrong
Simplify the product first, then integrate once:
 x^{2}\cdot x = x^{3} , so  \displaystyle\int x^{3}\,dx = \dfrac{x^{4}}{4} + C
 \dfrac{x^{4}}{4} + C  — correct
Differentiating settles which is which:
 \dfrac{d}{dx}\!\left(\dfrac{x^{4}}{4}\right) = x^{3}   but    \dfrac{d}{dx}\!\left(\dfrac{x^{5}}{6}\right) = \dfrac{5x^{4}}{6} \neq x^{3}

The two answers are not a small slip apart — they are different functions, and only  \dfrac{x^{4}}{4} + C differentiates back to  x^{3} .

Note What to do with a product instead

If the product simplifies, simplify it first and integrate once. Collecting  x^{2}\cdot x into  x^{3} is the whole job; the power rule then finishes it in one step.

If it will not simplify — a genuine function times a function, such as  \displaystyle\int x\,e^{x}\,dx — there is a dedicated technique called integration by parts, covered in a later lesson. Multiplying two separate integrals is never the way out.

Summary
  1. Integration distributes over  + and  - , never over  \times .
  2.  \displaystyle\int \big(f \pm g\big)\,dx = \int f\,dx \pm \int g\,dx ; there is no product version of this.
  3. Integrating each factor and multiplying gives the wrong answer:  \displaystyle\int x^{2}\cdot x\,dx = \dfrac{x^{4}}{4} + C , not  \dfrac{x^{5}}{6} .
  4. If the product simplifies, simplify first and integrate once.
  5. If it does not simplify, use integration by parts — a later lesson.