The Common Mistake in Integrating a Product

Integration distributes over addition and subtraction but never over multiplication. Integrating each factor of a product and multiplying the results is the single most common mistake in integration - here is why it fails, and what to do instead.

--
جارٍ تحميل الفيديو…

Integration splits neatly over addition and subtraction, so it feels as though it should split over multiplication in the same way. It does not. Integrating each factor of a product on its own and multiplying the results is the single most common mistake in integration.

Note Addition and subtraction really do split

Integration passes term by term through a sum or a difference:

Take , whose integral is . Break it up across a plus sign and integrate the pieces:

, so
⟹
Break it across a minus sign instead and the pieces still reassemble:
, so
⟹

Split the function however you like across and , integrate each part, and the answer always comes back correct.

Note Multiplication does not split

There is no matching rule for a product. Writing one down is the mistake:

Example Watch the wrong method fail

Integrate , first the wrong way, then the right way.

Integrate each factor separately and multiply the results:
⟹  — wrong
Simplify the product first, then integrate once:
, so
⟹  — correct
Differentiating settles which is which:
  but  

The two answers are not a small slip apart — they are different functions, and only differentiates back to .

Note What to do with a product instead

If the product simplifies, simplify it first and integrate once. Collecting into is the whole job; the power rule then finishes it in one step.

If it will not simplify — a genuine function times a function, such as — there is a dedicated technique called integration by parts, covered in a later lesson. Multiplying two separate integrals is never the way out.

Summary
  1. Integration distributes over and , never over .
  2. ; there is no product version of this.
  3. Integrating each factor and multiplying gives the wrong answer: , not .
  4. If the product simplifies, simplify first and integrate once.
  5. If it does not simplify, use integration by parts — a later lesson.